Four Of A Kind - Chapter 232: [4.50] Mon Étoile

The stage lights burned against Vivienne’s skin, and applause thundered through the entire auditorium. She held her final arabesque, leg extended behind her at the perfect angle, arms positioned with studied grace, spine straight as architectural steel. The music faded to silence. The heavy curtain descended with a whisper. Vivienne’s chest moved with controlled breaths, sweat cooling on her neck beneath the perfect bun Mrs. Chen had secured that afternoon with military precision.

Backstage carried the familiar cocktail of hairspray and rosin dust. The other girls from her ballet troupe clustered together, voices bubbling about the performance, about spotting their parents in the audience, about Madison’s party afterward. Vivienne tuned them out. She pressed a towel to her face and checked her phone with trembling fingers. The screen showed nothing. Papa was supposed to text when he arrived.

“Vivienne!” Her instructor materialized from the chaos—Miss Catherine with her steel-gray hair pulled into an unforgiving chignon and posture that could shame a military cadet. “Beautiful work tonight. Your extensions have improved remarkably since our last lesson.”

“Thank you, Miss Catherine.”

“Your father should be very proud of what he witnessed tonight.”

Vivienne’s pulse stuttered. “He’s here?”

“Front row. Right side. I saw him arrive just before curtain call.” Miss Catherine’s mouth curved into something approaching a smile, an expression so rare on her severe features that Vivienne wondered if she’d imagined it. “He looked positively radiant to be here.”

The dressing room transformed into a kaleidoscope of motion after that revelation. Vivienne changed into her street clothes with unprecedented speed, yanking the simple dress over her head, pulling bobby pins from her hair until dark red strands tumbled free. The other girls were still removing stage makeup when Vivienne grabbed her bag and pushed through the backstage door into the auditorium lobby.

Her father stood near the refreshment table like something from a magazine editorial—tall and elegant in his charcoal suit, wine-red hair combed to perfection. White roses filled his hands, petals pristine as fresh snow. Her favorite flowers.

“Papa!”

He turned at her voice. His entire face transformed, shadows melting away to reveal that smile. The one that made the universe feel manageable and bright.

“Mon étoile.” He opened his arms without hesitation. “You were absolutely magnificent out there.”

Vivienne launched herself at him, arms wrapping around his waist with desperate force. The roses crushed between them, silk-soft petals brushing her cheek. She was eleven years old and small enough that her father’s embrace felt like being wrapped in concentrated warmth and safety.

“I didn’t think you’d make it,” she mumbled against his jacket, voice muffled by expensive fabric. “Mama said you had that crucial meeting in Chicago.”

“I postponed it without a second thought.”

She pulled back far enough to stare up at him, eyes wide. “But it was important for the quarterly projections.”

“You’re infinitely more important.” He brushed an escaped strand of hair from her forehead, tucking it behind her ear with infinite gentleness. “Every meeting can be rescheduled for another day. But my daughter’s first solo performance? I wouldn’t miss it if the world was ending.”

The words settled into her chest like precious stones. Not the heavy kind that dragged you down, but the ones that anchored you to something solid and real.

“Tell me absolutely everything,” he said, guiding her toward one of the lobby’s plush benches. He sat down and patted the spot beside him with theatrical ceremony. “Were you nervous beforehand? Did you remember the entire fouetté sequence we practiced?”

Vivienne sank onto the bench and immediately leaned against his side. The performance’s exhaustion caught up with her in a rush, adrenaline draining away to leave her pleasantly hollow and tired.

“I was terrified. My hands were shaking so badly before the curtain went up.” She picked at the satin ribbon wrapped around the bouquet’s stems. “But then the opening notes started and I remembered what you taught me. About breathing from my center.”

“And how did that work for you?”

“Like magic. The shaking stopped completely.” She tilted her head to smile up at him. “I nailed every single turn. Even the triple pirouettes that have been giving me trouble.”

“I knew you would succeed. I never doubted it for a moment.”

“Mama didn’t come tonight.”

The words escaped before Vivienne could cage them. She felt his arm tighten around her shoulders—just slightly, just enough to register as a protective instinct.

“Your mother had pressing obligations. She desperately wanted to be here to support you.”

That was a lie wrapped in kindness. They both recognized it for what it was. Mama could have rescheduled just like Papa had. But Mama never rearranged board meetings for ballet recitals or school plays or anything that didn’t directly enhance the Valentine brand portfolio.

“It’s perfectly fine,” Vivienne said quietly, though her voice carried the smallest tremor. “You came. That’s what matters.”

“Always, mon étoile. Always and forever.”

They remained on the bench while other families filtered out of the auditorium around them. Parents showered their daughters with congratulations and pride. Madison’s mother wielded a professional camera like a weapon, documenting every angle. Someone’s little brother ran frantic circles around a marble column until he collapsed in a fit of giggles.

Papa asked about school with genuine interest. About her grades and whether they were still maintaining their usual standards. About friendship dynamics and whether the other girls had stopped making snide comments about her bringing elaborate lunches from home.

“They stopped commenting entirely after Cassidy threatened to fight them,” Vivienne admitted with reluctant amusement.

Papa’s laughter filled the space between them—that warm, rich sound that made the entire world feel safer and more manageable. “Your sister has very strong protective instincts.”

“She also has a very loud voice when she’s making threats.”

“That characteristic serves its purpose occasionally.”

The lobby gradually emptied around them. Ushers began switching off banks of lights, preparing for the evening’s end. Papa stood with fluid grace and offered his hand in a gesture that felt both courtly and completely natural.

“Come along, ma chérie. Let’s get you home before you fall asleep standing up. You must be completely exhausted.”