Every Mafia's Favorite Girl

Chapter 260: "Maybe I Want To Know"

  • Next Chapter

Jeremiah’s reaction to the recording was better than Aren had expected.

When she’d pressed play, she’d braced herself for an outburst. She’d imagined him becoming furious enough to throw a chair across the room, or at the very least, clenching his fists against the tabletop until his knuckles turned white.

Instead, throughout the recording, Jeremiah barely moved. His expression remained as composed as when he’d first sat down, without the slightest trace of the anger Aren herself had felt upon overhearing the conversation.

When the recording ended, he simply reached across the table and locked the screen for her. Then he sat quietly for a while, so still that Aren couldn’t begin to guess what he was thinking.

Eventually, he looked at her.

"Miss Lombardi, just out of curiosity, were you a sub or a domme when you visited those sex dungeons?"

Aren stared at him.

"...Hah?"

Of all the reactions she’d prepared herself for, that particular question hadn’t occurred to her even once, yet Jeremiah regarded her as though he’d asked something perfectly reasonable.

"I mean..." He rubbed his chin thoughtfully. "I already knew you had quite a wild sex life, and perhaps you’re fond of a few unusual fetishes, too. But to be perfectly honest, I never expected you to visit an establishment like that private pleasure club."

Once again, Aren found herself at a loss for words. She continued staring at him, although her expression had grown distinctly less sympathetic.

"...Is that seriously the first thing that comes to your mind after hearing this recording?"

"Well, there’s certainly nothing to be ashamed of," he assured her with an easy shrug. "It’s just that, had I known you enjoyed such places, I would’ve invited you to go with me sometime."

"Jeremy," Aren said, stressing his name as her patience began to wear thin. "I’m not going to a sex club with you."

"Oh, is it still too early in our relationship?" Jeremiah brightened. "Well, I’m glad to hear your preferences firsthand, at least. It’ll help me accommodate you properly when the time is right. So, were you a sub or a domme? Just so you know, I’m quite flexible myself."

By now, Aren was beginning to understand why Jordan had developed such a profound dislike of Jeremiah Castellano. If this was how the man behaved whenever he found an opportunity to tease someone, then Jordan must have endured a considerable amount of it during all the years they’d known each other.

"Jeremy," she repeated, fixing him with the sternest expression she could manage. "We have a much more important problem to solve than my sexual preferences. What do you intend to do about what we just heard?"

That finally seemed to restore some seriousness to Jeremiah’s expression. His bright smile faded, leaving something faintly bitter in its place.

"Well, what other choice do I have now? I suppose I’ll just hire a sniper to put a bullet through each of my parents’ heads. Not exactly the elaborate revenge drama I had in mind, but it’ll have to do."

He slid the device back across the table toward her, then rose from his chair as though the matter had been settled.

"You’re still on medical leave, aren’t you? Shall I call my driver to take you home?"

Only then did Aren notice something familiar about the way he was behaving. She knew she wasn’t particularly skilled at reading other people’s intentions, but the more time she spent with Jeremiah, the more she’d begun to recognize certain patterns in his behavior.

Whenever a conversation approached something he didn’t want to discuss, he had a remarkable talent for steering it elsewhere. He would make a joke, introduce some outrageous suggestion, or simply change the subject until the original question was forgotten.

’He’s doing that again.’

Her brows drew together.

"Look, I’ve had enough rest by now. But... what about you? Are you all right?"

Jeremiah didn’t answer.

His face brightened again.

"Do you know how to paint?"

Aren’s frown deepened.

She’d asked him a perfectly straightforward question, and somehow he’d managed to respond with something entirely unrelated yet again.

"No, I don’t know how to paint," she replied curtly. "Why are you asking?"

"Would you like to learn?" he asked, tilting his head.

"Jeremy," Aren insisted, refusing to let him distract her again. "You still haven’t answered my question."

Her persistence seemed to delight him. He chuckled softly, though there was something faintly indulgent in his eyes as he took in her irritated expression.

"Well, the thing is, I was just thinking... if you’ve already had enough rest for now, perhaps you’d like to spend a little time painting with me instead?"

? ?? ?? ?? ?

Color was something Jeremiah understood exceptionally well, or at least that was the conclusion Aren reached after watching him work. He’d started with only a few basic colors, yet after several careful combinations, he’d somehow produced an entire palette of shades ready for painting.

They sat together on two stools before a large canvas in the painting studio of Jeremiah’s private mansion.

The immaculate suit he’d worn at Castellano Club that morning was gone. He now wore a white shirt, its sleeves rolled up and collar left open, which Aren thought was a rather bold choice for someone about to work with paint.

"So, what would you like to start with?" he asked, gesturing toward the blank canvas.

Aren considered the question.

"Hmm. Perhaps the sea. Like the one we saw at the Prism Gallery."

"Oh?" Jeremiah sounded surprised. "Any particular reason you chose that one?"

"It looked peaceful," she answered simply. "If I could make a painting that peaceful, and someone found peace in looking at it too, I think that would be wonderful."

A smile appeared on Jeremiah’s face, although he turned away before she could notice it. He picked up a pencil and began sketching the scene as best he remembered it, lightly marking the horizon and the contours of the sea across the canvas.

"You know, Miss Lombardi, you’re quite different from everything I’ve heard about you."

Aren stiffened slightly.

She’d been watching his pencil move across the canvas, but his remark made her glance toward him with a hint of hesitation.

It wasn’t the first time someone had noticed the difference between her and the Ariana Lombardi they remembered. She answered as she always did.

"People change a lot over time, don’t they? It’s only natural that I’ve changed too."

She hesitated, wondering whether it would be appropriate to turn the question around. After a moment, she decided to ask anyway.

"What about you? You must have changed a lot too since... back then."

Jeremiah’s pencil paused.

A moment later, he resumed sketching.

"I don’t think so. I’m still the same person I’ve always been. I’ve simply learned to control which parts of myself other people get to see."

Aren fell quiet as she watched him work.

There was something peaceful about him now, something she found difficult to reconcile with the flamboyant man who presided over the Pit, and seemed to take pleasure in creating chaos wherever he went.

Here, sitting before a canvas with a pencil in his hand, he seemed more relaxed and down-to-earth, so far removed from the version of him she encountered in public that she almost felt she was spending time with someone else.

"Don’t you worry that people might misunderstand who you are?"

Jeremiah paused and turned.

She was already looking at him.

"I’m sure I still don’t know you very well," she continued, "but... to tell you the truth, when we’re alone like this, you seem very different from the person you are in front of other people."

She hesitated, searching for the right way to express what she meant.

"I feel like... I prefer you this way. And I think it’s a shame that most people only ever get to know Jeremiah Castellano."

A small smile touched his lips, although something quieter passed through his eyes. He set the pencil down and turned to face her fully, as though the conversation had become too important to divide his attention between her and the painting.

"Didn’t you say it yourself?" he asked. "Whatever assumptions people might make about me, at the end of the day, who really knows me but myself?"

Aren lowered her gaze.

She was surprised he’d remembered her words well enough to repeat them now, but she could understand his reasoning well enough. People could misunderstand one another for all sorts of reasons, and she knew from experience that other people’s assumptions didn’t necessarily reflect who someone truly was.

Still, something about Jeremiah’s answer struck her as rather lonely. She fell quiet, considering what to say.

The silence lasted long enough that Jeremiah assumed the conversation had ended. He was just about to turn back toward the canvas when she spoke again.

"Maybe I want to know."

Her voice was quiet, almost casual, but the words brought him to a complete standstill. He turned to look at her, his eyes widening as though he wasn’t certain he’d heard correctly.

’...Did she really just say that?’

As far as Jeremiah was concerned, their relationship had already become complicated enough.

He’d spent a considerable amount of time trying to understand what she meant to him, and every time he thought he’d found a sensible way to keep those feelings under control, she would say or do something that made the whole situation even more difficult.

Now, she’d told him she wanted to know the parts of himself he deliberately kept hidden from everyone else.

’No.’

He bit his lip.

’This is not good.’

’This is getting far too complicated.’

Eventually, habit came to his rescue.

"Then perhaps we could start by visiting a private pleasure club together?"

Aren’s expression fell so quickly that Jeremiah nearly burst out laughing. She fixed him with a thoroughly irritated glare before turning sharply back toward the canvas, her lips settling into a pout.

"I take back everything I said."

That was enough to destroy whatever remained of Jeremiah’s composure. He burst into laughter, bending forward and clutching his stomach as he struggled to contain himself.

"Ha ha ha—!"

Aren turned toward him again, her displeasure growing with every passing second.

"Stop laughing! Or I’m leaving! No more painting!"

"No, sorry! Don’t leave!" He managed between laughs. "I can’t help it!"

"Jeremy!"

She rose abruptly from her stool, looking fully prepared to make good on her threat. But just as she turned away, Jeremiah reached for her.

"Wait!"

He caught her wrist before she could walk away. When she turned to look at him, the laughter had faded from his expression.

"Don’t leave."

Aren went still.

He was looking at her with a quiet earnestness she hadn’t quite seen from him before. When she didn’t respond, he gave her wrist another small tug, a pleading smile spreading across his face.

"Please, I’m sorry. Don’t leave."

Warmth rushed into Aren’s cheeks, sudden and intense. She pulled her wrist free, although instead of heading toward the door, she drew her stool back into position and sat down again.

"All right, Jeremy, listen carefully," she began, adopting the sternest voice she could manage. "If you ever bring up that pleasure club again, I’m going to refuse to speak to you for an entire week. And I don’t care how many times you apologize, I absolutely will not—"

CRASH!

Thoom!

"Hurgh—!"

Aren froze.

The unmistakable sound of shattering glass had erupted behind her, followed almost immediately by a gunshot and Jeremiah’s pained grunt.

’What the...?’

Blood splattered across the white canvas, bright red against the unfinished sketch in the sunlight. When Aren whipped around, Jeremiah was still beside her, but blood was spreading across the front of his white shirt.

"JEREMY!"

She lunged toward him, catching him before he could fall.

If you find any errors (non-standard content, ads redirect, broken links, etc..), Please let us know so we can fix it as soon as possible.

Report

Use arrow keys (or A / D) to PREV/NEXT chapter