Chapter 60: The Gremlin becomes a Goblin

 "Umm..."

I stayed in place, pinned to the couch by a horny gremlin. 

Her bespectacled black eyes staring deeply into mine. 

Her breathing is hot, and heavy. Ticking my skin with every exhale.

 'This... is Isami making her move, isn't it? Sure, I may have caused it, but she's the one who went for it.'

Acknowledging the situation, I swallow my spit, and part my lips.

"Okay... Let's try it."

"!! Yes!"  

The moment I gave my consent, Isami burst into a big stupid smile,

I considered taking this to her room, but then I remembered how the walls are covered in posters of anime boys.

'I'd rather not cum then look up and see a random dude smiling at me.'

 So if I'm going to have my first time with Isami, I'd rather it be on her couch.

"Leave everything to me, Andy! I'll show you heaven!"  Isami boldly declared. 

She gets off me, and places a foot on the floor.

"Wait."

"Huh? What is it, Andy?"

At my call, Isami stopped before she could move her right knee off the couch.

"Isami, do you like me?" 

At my question, Isami hangs her mouth open slightly.

She blinks once, twice.

"Y-Yeah. I like you a lot. You're..." 

Isami blushes, and looks away. Scratching the back of her head soon after.

"You're the only man who doesn't ignore me because of my height... You tease me, but you don't actually mean it. You always reply to my messages even if they're just memes, you give me home cooked meals, and you hangout with me often. How could I..."

Isami faces me again. Her eyes meeting mine.

"How could I not fall in love with you?"  The confession genuine on her lips.

"I lied. I don't just like you. I love you, Andy."  As she muttered the words I wanted to hear, her eyes began to water.

"I know I'm below average. I know I'm not rich. I know my body is lacking, but I- Mmph!?"

Unable to bear her self-deprecation any longer, I shut her mouth using my own.

Pushing my tongue into her mouth, I quickly turn it into a mature kiss.

Though caught off guard, Isami eventually returned the favor.

Wrestling her tongue against mine.

"Hmph- Haa- Mmm..." 

Sensual noises escaped us both as we tasted each other's spit.

But soon, I pulled away. A thin bridge of saliva connected our lips for a second before breaking apart.

"Isami, do you want to be my fourth girlfriend?"  I asked, choosing not to hide the state of my love life.

At the offer, Isami went wide eyed for a couple breaths.

"...... Yes. If you'll have me, then I'll gladly be your girlfriend, Andy."  Isami said. Her lips curled into a smile as tears began dripping down her cheek.

"... You're not offended or anything I already have three girlfriends?"  

"No."

Isami instantly replied, lightly shaking her head.

"Takamine-san already told me she's your second, and that you're seeing a third woman."

She paused for a beat, then opens her mouth again.

"But honestly, I didn't care. I just wished I could have a spot next to you. No matter how many women you're seeing."

Isami breathes. Her flat chest rising as she did.

"I'm... that desperate. I want you that much, Andy."

"Isami..." 

"I promise I'll do my best. I won't disappoint you, Andy. I won't-"

"... I won't make you regret making me your girlfriend."

"So please..."

Her voice started to shake.

She looks straight at me, teary-eyed.

"Please don't abandon me..."

Isami's plea, it was raw.

I felt it then that it came from somewhere deep inside her.

A depth I can't reach. At least not now.

'Instead of a gremlin, she looks like a small animal right now.'

I lean in, and press my lips against hers.

Then pulled back soon after.

"....."

Before going in for another.

Each kiss felt like an affirmation. Like I was telling her that this-

This is real. 

"You said you'd show me heaven, right?"

The corners of my lips rise.

"Then show it to me, Isami."

"!! Y-Yes!"

Isami gets off me. Both feet planted on the floor.

She bends over, hands reaching for the waistline of my shorts.

But she stops, and clenched her fists.

Instead, she grabbed the hem of my shirt. Then pulled it up.

'She thought about going straight for my shorts, but changed her mind, didn't she?'

Isami's hesitation only served to reveal how inexperienced she truly is.

And I couldn't help but find it cute.

'I might have to lead her.'

Naturally, I complied with my own undressing. Raising my arms so Isami can smoothly take off my shirt.

As she pulled it over my head, I caught a glimpse of her nervous expression.

And when she had completely taken off my shirt, I saw that same expression change into one of desire.

Her mouth hanged open for a moment before she closed it.

Her eyes hanged low, staring at my bare chest. And I saw her throat flex as she swallowed her spit.

'I'll never get the appeal of a man's chest to women. Both in my old world and in this one.'

Isami raised her hands, and slowly pushed them towards my chest. Fingers spread apart, ready to grasp.

"Isami."

"Huh?! Y-Yes!?" 

Isami frantically looked up to meet my eyes. Her hands stopping in their tracks.

"It's not fair if I'm the only one topless, right?"  I say. The corners of my lips pointing up.

"A-Ah, right."

Then, Isami looked down at herself, and grabbed the hem of her box shirt. Pulling it over her head in one motion before tossing it to the floor alongside my discarded shirt.

"I can continue now r- IGHT?!"

Isami gasped, caught off guard by me latching on to her bare chest.

'Such cute breasts.'  I thought, running my tongue across her nipple.

"Eep! S-Stop! That feels weird!"  Isami said, her cheeks flushed red. 

Her back arched slightly, pushing her tight little ass out.

But I didn't stop.

I want to taste more of Isami. To lick and suck on her flat chest some more.

'I thought chests this flat only existed in fiction. I never thought Isami would have one.'

Some might ask, "What's the appeal in flat chests? There's nothing there."

And in a way, they're right. But a chest is still a chest.

'I don't know about others, but as long as it belongs to a woman I love, it doesn't matter how big or small her breasts are. They each have their own charm, and I'll love them all the same.'

Isami's hands hang in the air, hesitant to push me away.

'N-No..! Why am I enjoying having my boobs touched like this?! I-It feels weird!'

Yet, Isami couldn't say that it didn't feel good. Because as a woman born and raised in this reversed world, the idea of feeling it from her chest was foreign, but not unheard of. It's just Isami never imagined she'd be one of them.

'I should be the one playing with Andy's chest! Not the other way around!'

Then, I pulled away.

'Finally! My tur-'

And grabbed Isami by the waist.

"Eh?"

Ignoring the noise that escaped her lips, I lifted her up and laid her on the couch.

'As the one with more experience, I should be the one to lead, right?'

Though I did say I wanted Isami to "show me heaven," and it would be adorable watching her try to lead, I decided it would be better if I led this time and let her top next time. 

With that said, I grabbed the waistline of her shorts and pulled them down.

"....... What?"

And what stared back at me were several cutesy anime boys printed on her panties.

I look up.

Isami had short-circuited. Her expression one of utter shock; eyes blown wide open, jaw dropped.

'... I shouldn't laugh. If I so much as let out a chuckle, she'd die of embarrassment.'

Forcing myself not to react, I pinched the sides of her panties and pulled them off. Quickly discarding them to the floor.

Underneath me lies Isami in her purest form. Ah, save for her glasses.

'I know she's older, but damn her body is petite enough that she looks younger than me.'

I lean in, and steal a kiss from her lips.

"Mmgh ♥"

Then I trailed down, peppering her heated skin with kisses.

Her cheek, neck, collarbone, all the way down to her cleanly shaven entrance.

Every time my lips made contact with her skin, Isami trembled.

'At this point, I've lost count how many times I've called Isami cute just today alone.'

But how could I not when she looks like this?

Moving on, my eyes trailed back to her increasingly wet pussy.

'... I wonder what this hole tastes like.'

Curious, I bury my face into her heat. Sticking my tongue out, I give Isami's pussy a heavy lick.

"Hmph-!"  Isami gasped in response.

'Hm... Salty and... sweet? That's definitely a first.'

"H-Hey..."  Isami called out. I look and see her staring at me with a pleading look on her face.

"Put it in already..."  she said in a quiet, timid voice. Pushing her hips closer to me as she did.

'So fucking cute.'

Turning around, I grab the square pillow behind me and place it under her rear. Elevating it to make insertion comfortable.

"Alright I'll- Huh?"

I suddenly felt something tugging at the waistline of my shorts.

I look down and see Isami's toes clawing at it, attempting to pull them down.

Glancing at her face, I can see her biting her lower lip.

'Ha- I forgot how much of a pervert she is.'

Hooking the garter, I finally pull down my shorts. Taking my underwear along with it.

"!! So this is what a real penis looks like up close..!"  Isami commented, staring right at my exposed member.

And needless to say I'm already erect from all the foreplay.

Grabbing my length, I press it against her wet heat.

"I'm putting it in now, Isami."

"Mhm..!"  Isami nodded, biting her lower lip in anticipation.

"Alright. Here I go..!"

With a roll of my hips, I push my cock into Isami.

Or at least, I tried to.

"Eh..? Why won't it..."

I push harder, but the head still won't penetrate.

"Andy..?"

'How is it possible for a pussy to be so tight that it won't go in even when it's drenched?'

Adjusting my strategy, I grab Isami's hips and angle her upwards. Now putting my weight behind it, I finally managed to penetrate Isami.

"Hmmmngh!!"  Isami exclaimed, biting down on her lower lip to hold back her moans.

'It's inside! I finally lost my damn V card! And it's with Andy no less! I can die happy!'

"Andy, how does my pussy feel- Huh?"  

Overjoyed at losing her virginity, Isami looked at me at with a proud smile on her face. But when she saw me visibly trembling, that same smile faltered.

"Hoo..! Hoo...!"  I took deep, labored breaths. Trying to adjust to the insanely tight sensation around my dick.

'How- can Isami be this tight..?! It feels like my dick might get torn off!'

The impossibly tight squeeze around my member is suffocating to say the least. Yet, it strangely isn't painful. It's suffocating, but feels incredible at the same time.

'Shit..! I'm supposed to lead Isami, but I can't even move..!'

It's taking everything I have not to cum. If I so much as move, or worse, if Isami takes over and starts pounding me, I'd blow in less than a minute.

'Please stay still, Isami...!'

But as if hearing my thoughts, Isami opened her mouth.

"Hey, Andy, is my pussy... tight?"

"So fucking tight!"  I confessed immediately before I could think about it.

Barely within the scope of my vision, I saw the corners of Isami's lips rise into a wicked grin.

"Tighter than your other girlfriends?"

"... Mhm..!"

After a second of deliberation, I quickly nodded.

Isami opened her mouth, and showed me a teethy grin. 

Then, without warning, Isami lunged forward. Toppling me over until my back hit the cushions.

"Agh- What..."

I look up, and see Isami gazing down at me with a smile that's as if she has the world in her palm.

The moment Isami went from being below me to now riding me, the roles had been flipped.

"Isami, hold on- Haagh!?"

Without letting me finish, Isami rolled her hips. The walls of her pussy scraping tightly against my cock when she did.

"Does it feel good, Andy?"  Isami asked in a teasing voice.

"Yes! It feels amazing! So give me a minute to get used to it!"  I pleaded to Isami who undoubtedly holds control over me in this situation.

My hands frantically grip the couch until my knuckles turn white. Desperately holding on for dear life.

'If she starts pounding me right now, then I..!'

Fearing the worst, I fervently hope Isami will listen to my request and not move.

"Haaggh!!"

"Hooo fuck..!"

But deep down, I knew she wouldn't listen. Disregarding my wish, Isami slowly raised her hips. Her inner walls cling obsessively to the first real cock they have ever tasted.

"Please, Isami! If you move now, I might break..!!"

At my words, Isami stopped in place. Her lips curl into a grin as she bares her teeth.

"You might break, you say..?" 

"Y-Yeah, so don't m- OVE?!"

Without warning, Isami slammed her hips down at full force. The impact elicited a sharp gasp from my throat.

"THEN BREAK!"

Isami yelled before raising her hips and slamming them back down in quick succession.

"Break for me, Andy! Show me what you look like when you're fucked stupid! Your brain turned to mush because of my cunt! Show them to me, Andy!!"

Overflowing with confidence, Isami immediately set a brutal pace. Pounding me into the cushions without any semblance of decency.

As for any attempt of resistance?

"Ha- Haa- Haaangg!!"

I couldn't even think of it, or anything for that matter.

Isami's impossibly tight pussy, the pleasure it gives with every rise, every squelch had me seeing stars.

It's only after surviving this event did I later change my image of Isami.

She isn't a gremlin, but a goblin who had been hiding her poisoned dagger this whole time.

'I, have to- hold on!!'

At this moment, every ounce of focus I have is centered around my dick. 

"Heh- Heheheh! You look so sexy right now, Andy! Like the boys in doujins!"  Isami teased as she savored whatever expression I was making right now.

The sight of her petite form slamming her hips down on my cock only heightened the pleasure even more. 

Enough for me to cum right this second if I let my guard down.

But my pride as a man won't allow me to cum so soon. If I did, I'll never live it down!

'Don't cum- Don't cum- Don't cum- Do not fucking cummmm!!'

My thoughts were filled with my fervent wish not to blow.

And I held on for as long as I could. Even if every second felt like eternity, I held on until my cock couldn't take it anymore.

"Haagh! I-Isami, I'm cumming! Pull out! Pull out!!"  I pleaded, recalling the fact that I didn't take the pill beforehand.

Meaning, if I came inside Isami now- then she could get pregnant. A baby could be made right this moment!

"No!"  Isami gasped, her voice coming out raw.

"It's a safe day- so cum inside me, Andy! I want to feel your cum sloshing around inside me!"

Hearing that- the last wall I put up had been breached. There was nothing else holding me back from cumming irresponsibly.

So I came. My cock exploded inside Isami's tight heat. Painting her insides white with my seed.

"Haaahh!!" 

At the same time, Isami reached her peak as well. Throwing her head back, she sprayed her juices all over me. Dragging her nails over my chest, she scored animal-like claw marks on me. The pain mixing with the mind numbing pleasure.

For the duration of my orgasm, my vision flickered white, like a lightbulb turning on and off.

And when our mutual orgasm finally ended, our bodies went limp. Isami's petite form collapsed on top of me like a doll with its strings cut.

"Haa... Haa...."

"Hooo... Haa..."

Neither of us uttered a word. Both too exhausted, too busy recovering after what just happened.

'Insane...'

When I recovered enough strength to move a little, I raised my neck and pressed a kiss on the top of her head.

"That was amazing, Isami..."  The compliment genuine on my lips. 

'That might have been the most incredible sex I've had yet...'

"I didn't know you had it in you."  I added.

"..... Hmmngh..."

Without responding, Isami rubbed her sweat-soaked head all over my chest. 

"I'm glad my first time was with you, Andy... And not with some random guy at a Soapland..."

"... Yeah."

I raise my hand, and caress her head.

"You did well holding on all this time, but now that we're together, you don't have to hold back anymore. You can use me anytime you want. Granted I'm not busy, of course."

"!"

The moment I said that, Isami propped herself up. Both hands pushing against my chest.

"Then could we go for another round- No, make it two!"  

Isami's eyes sparkled with excitement. Lips parted to form a wide, open smile.

"Uh- um, maybe let me rest for a few more minutes-"

"! No- You're going soft!"

Isami sat back up and proceeded to roll her hips back and forth.

"Haggh?! Isami- Wait-"

But as if betraying my wishes, my cock returned to full mast. Ready for round two.

Feeling the cock inside her go hard again, Isami grinned.

"Let's keep going until your balls are empty, Andy!"

"No- Listen to me- You damn gremlinnnn!!"

=======================